Skip to content

ToolGrade vs Toolproof

ToolGrade is a free MCP server for developer tools. Toolproof is a free MCP server for security.

  • Toolproof is open source; ToolGrade is not.
  • ToolGrade is best for check an mcp server's tool schemas before publishing.
  • Toolproof is best for grade an unfamiliar mcp server before adding it to a client.
What it is
ToolGrade is a free MCP server for developer tools.
Toolproof is a free MCP server for security.
Best for
Check an MCP server's tool schemas before publishing
Grade an unfamiliar MCP server before adding it to a client
Kind
MCP server
MCP server
Pricing
Free
Free
Platforms
Web, API
CLI, API, Web
Runs
Remotely
Locally
Open source
Good for
Check an MCP server's tool schemas before publishing; Let a coding agent grade the server it is building; Find tools with vague descriptions or untyped parameters
Grade an unfamiliar MCP server before adding it to a client; Stop hidden Unicode instructions reaching the model; Fail a pull request when a pinned tool changes its parameters

What ToolGrade does

  • Agent-readiness score

    Rates tool definitions from 0 to 100 with an A to F grade.

  • Per-tool findings

    Lists specific fixes such as missing types, maxLength and annotations.

  • Token cost estimate

    Estimates how many tokens the definitions will use.

  • JSON API

    POST a tools/list JSON file to the grading endpoint.

  • Optional free key

    A no-signup key raises the limit to about 100 grades a month.

What Toolproof does

  • Letter-grade scans

    Paste a server URL and get a grade with every finding and the exact text behind it.

  • Wrap mode

    Sits in the path to drop deceptive tools and redact injected instructions mid-stream.

  • Capability lockfile

    Pins the approved tool surface and fails the build when it drifts.

  • Signed verdicts

    Each verdict is an ed25519 passport verifiable offline.

  • Agent rule

    One pasted rule makes an agent verify a server before connecting.

  • CI gate

    A --fail-under score fails a job when a server grades too low.

ToolGrade vs Toolproof: questions

Is ToolGrade or Toolproof cheaper?

Both are free. Compare current plans on each official site.

What is the difference between ToolGrade and Toolproof?

ToolGrade is a free MCP server for developer tools. Toolproof is a free MCP server for security. Toolproof is open source; ToolGrade is not.

Keep comparing