ToolGrade vs Toolproof
ToolGrade is a free MCP server for developer tools. Toolproof is a free MCP server for security.
- Toolproof is open source; ToolGrade is not.
- ToolGrade is best for check an mcp server's tool schemas before publishing.
- Toolproof is best for grade an unfamiliar mcp server before adding it to a client.
- What it is
- ToolGrade is a free MCP server for developer tools.Toolproof is a free MCP server for security.
- Best for
- Check an MCP server's tool schemas before publishingGrade an unfamiliar MCP server before adding it to a client
- Kind
- MCP serverMCP server
- Pricing
- FreeFree
- Platforms
- Web, APICLI, API, Web
- Runs
- RemotelyLocally
- Open source
- Good for
- Check an MCP server's tool schemas before publishing; Let a coding agent grade the server it is building; Find tools with vague descriptions or untyped parametersGrade an unfamiliar MCP server before adding it to a client; Stop hidden Unicode instructions reaching the model; Fail a pull request when a pinned tool changes its parameters
What ToolGrade does
Agent-readiness score
Rates tool definitions from 0 to 100 with an A to F grade.
Per-tool findings
Lists specific fixes such as missing types, maxLength and annotations.
Token cost estimate
Estimates how many tokens the definitions will use.
JSON API
POST a tools/list JSON file to the grading endpoint.
Optional free key
A no-signup key raises the limit to about 100 grades a month.
What Toolproof does
Letter-grade scans
Paste a server URL and get a grade with every finding and the exact text behind it.
Wrap mode
Sits in the path to drop deceptive tools and redact injected instructions mid-stream.
Capability lockfile
Pins the approved tool surface and fails the build when it drifts.
Signed verdicts
Each verdict is an ed25519 passport verifiable offline.
Agent rule
One pasted rule makes an agent verify a server before connecting.
CI gate
A --fail-under score fails a job when a server grades too low.
ToolGrade vs Toolproof: questions
Is ToolGrade or Toolproof cheaper?
Both are free. Compare current plans on each official site.
What is the difference between ToolGrade and Toolproof?
ToolGrade is a free MCP server for developer tools. Toolproof is a free MCP server for security. Toolproof is open source; ToolGrade is not.