Skip to content

Security review vs Sharp edges

Security review is an open-source agent skill for security. Sharp edges is an open-source agent skill for security.

  • Security review has more GitHub stars (41,254 vs 8,243).
  • Security review is best for check my repository for sql injection or xss before a release.
  • Sharp edges is best for review an api design for insecure defaults before release.
What it is
Security review is an open-source agent skill for security.
Sharp edges is an open-source agent skill for security.
Best for
Check my repository for SQL injection or XSS before a release
Review an API design for insecure defaults before release
Kind
Skill
Skill
Pricing
Open source
Open source
Platforms
Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Windsurf, Goose
Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Windsurf, Goose
GitHub stars
41.3K
8.2K
Last commit
Nov 2026
Nov 2026
License
MIT
CC-BY-SA-4.0
Open source
Good for
Check my repository for SQL injection or XSS before a release; Scan the project for hardcoded API keys and credentials; Audit package.json and lock files for vulnerable dependencies
Review an API design for insecure defaults before release; Audit a configuration schema for options that disable security; Assess the ergonomics of a cryptographic library interface

What Security review does

  • Dependency vulnerability audit

    Checks manifests and lock files across npm, Python, Java, Ruby, Rust and Go against a CVE watchlist.

  • Secrets exposure scan

    Looks for hardcoded keys, tokens, private keys, connection strings and committed env files, including CI and IaC files.

  • Injection flaw detection

    Reasons about SQL, command, XSS and other injection paths by tracing user input to sinks.

  • Access control review

    Examines authentication, authorization, JWT handling, CSRF and privilege escalation paths.

  • Cross-file data flow tracing

    Follows input across modules and services to find issues that only appear when files are read together.

  • Severity-rated report

    Produces findings with severity, confidence, file location and plain-English risk explanations.

What Sharp edges does

  • Misuse-resistance review workflow

    A four-phase process from mapping choice points through validating findings.

  • Edge case probing

    Checks zero, empty, null, negative and type-confused inputs against security decisions.

  • Threat modeling perspectives

    Considers a malicious config author, a copy-paste developer and a confused developer.

  • Dangerous default detection

    Flags defaults and configuration options that can disable security entirely.

  • Severity grading

    Ranks findings from critical to low based on how easily misuse occurs.

  • Language-specific references

    Supplies footgun guides for many languages plus crypto, auth and config patterns.

Security review vs Sharp edges: questions

Is Security review or Sharp edges cheaper?

Both are open source. Compare current plans on each official site.

What is the difference between Security review and Sharp edges?

Security review is an open-source agent skill for security. Sharp edges is an open-source agent skill for security. Security review has more GitHub stars (41,254 vs 8,243).

Keep comparing