Skip to content

Code review vs Second opinion

Code review is an open-source agent skill for developer tools. Second opinion is an open-source agent skill for developer tools.

  • Code review has more GitHub stars (326,295 vs 8,243).
  • Code review is best for review everything on a feature branch since it left main.
  • Second opinion is best for get a second opinion on my uncommitted changes before committing.
What it is
Code review is an open-source agent skill for developer tools.
Second opinion is an open-source agent skill for developer tools.
Best for
Review everything on a feature branch since it left main
Get a second opinion on my uncommitted changes before committing
Kind
Skill
Skill
Pricing
Open source
Open source
Platforms
Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Windsurf, Goose
Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, Windsurf, Goose
GitHub stars
326K
8.2K
Last commit
Nov 2026
Nov 2026
License
MIT
CC-BY-SA-4.0
Open source
Good for
Review everything on a feature branch since it left main; Check a PR against the issue it claims to close; Review work-in-progress changes since a given commit
Get a second opinion on my uncommitted changes before committing; Compare Codex and Antigravity reviews of a feature branch against main; Review a specific commit for security issues

What Code review does

  • Fixed-point diff

    Pins the comparison to a supplied ref and validates it before delegating.

  • Standards axis

    Checks the diff against documented repo standards and cites the rule for each breach.

  • Code smell baseline

    Adds twelve Fowler smells as labelled heuristics that repo standards can override.

  • Spec axis

    Reports missing requirements, scope creep and implementations that look wrong, quoting the spec.

  • Parallel subagents

    Runs both reviews in fresh contexts so one does not influence the other.

  • Separate reporting

    Keeps the two reports distinct and summarizes the worst finding per axis.

What Second opinion does

  • Multiple review providers

    Choose Codex, Antigravity, or the Gemini CLI, or run two providers side by side for a comparison.

  • Flexible review scope

    Review uncommitted changes including untracked files, a branch diff against a base, or a specific commit.

  • Shared input capture

    Sends the same captured diff and prompt to every provider so comparisons cover identical changes.

  • Structured findings

    Reports severity, file and line, impact, and suggested fix, sorted by severity with low-severity items kept visible.

  • Failure reporting

    Flags missing CLIs, auth problems, quota limits, and invalid output as incomplete rather than clean reviews.

  • Safe temporary files

    Writes prompts, outputs, and diagnostics to mktemp files outside the checkout.

Code review vs Second opinion: questions

Is Code review or Second opinion cheaper?

Both are open source. Compare current plans on each official site.

What is the difference between Code review and Second opinion?

Code review is an open-source agent skill for developer tools. Second opinion is an open-source agent skill for developer tools. Code review has more GitHub stars (326,295 vs 8,243).

Keep comparing