Skip to content

Code maturity assessor vs Guidelines advisor

Code maturity assessor is an open-source agent skill for security. Guidelines advisor is an open-source agent skill for security.

  • Code maturity assessor is best for score the security maturity of a solidity project before an audit.
  • Guidelines advisor is best for review my solidity project against trail of bits best practices.
What it is
Code maturity assessor is an open-source agent skill for security.
Guidelines advisor is an open-source agent skill for security.
Best for
Score the security maturity of a Solidity project before an audit
Review my Solidity project against Trail of Bits best practices
Kind
Skill
Skill
Pricing
Open source
Open source
Platforms
Claude Code
Claude Code
GitHub stars
8.2K
8.2K
Last commit
Nov 2026
Nov 2026
License
CC-BY-SA-4.0
CC-BY-SA-4.0
Open source
Good for
Score the security maturity of a Solidity project before an audit; Review how well a DeFi codebase is tested and documented; Identify access control and upgrade risks in a smart contract repo
Review my Solidity project against Trail of Bits best practices; Check whether my proxy and upgrade setup follows delegatecall guidelines; Assess the inheritance structure and events of my contracts

What Code maturity assessor does

  • Nine-category maturity rubric

    Evaluates arithmetic, access control, complexity, decentralization, documentation, transaction ordering, low-level code, auditing and testing.

  • Five-level rating scale

    Assigns each category a rating from missing to strong using defined threshold logic.

  • Evidence-based findings

    Ties each rating to specific code locations and files.

  • Interactive process questions

    Asks the user about monitoring, incident response and team practices that code alone cannot show.

  • Prioritized improvement roadmap

    Groups recommended improvements into critical, high and medium priority tiers with effort estimates.

  • Structured report output

    Produces an executive summary, scorecard table and detailed category analysis.

What Guidelines advisor does

  • Codebase discovery

    Maps contract files, existing documentation, test locations, proxies and dependencies before reviewing.

  • Architecture review

    Assesses on-chain versus off-chain split, upgradeability trade-offs and delegatecall proxy patterns.

  • Implementation quality checks

    Reviews function size, inheritance depth, event coverage and naming consistency.

  • Pitfall identification

    Checks for reentrancy, overflow, access control and platform-specific issues.

  • Dependency and test assessment

    Evaluates library quality, version management, coverage, fuzzing and formal verification use.

  • Prioritized recommendations

    Groups findings into critical, high, medium and low priority with next steps.

Code maturity assessor vs Guidelines advisor: questions

Is Code maturity assessor or Guidelines advisor cheaper?

Both are open source. Compare current plans on each official site.

What is the difference between Code maturity assessor and Guidelines advisor?

Code maturity assessor is an open-source agent skill for security. Guidelines advisor is an open-source agent skill for security.

Keep comparing