Skip to content

Citadel vs cogvault

Citadel is an open-source MCP server for knowledge and memory. cogvault is an open-source MCP server for knowledge and memory.

  • Citadel is best for give a desktop assistant private long-term memory.
  • cogvault is best for give a coding agent persistent decisions and bug fix notes.
What it is
Citadel is an open-source MCP server for knowledge and memory.
cogvault is an open-source MCP server for knowledge and memory.
Best for
Give a desktop assistant private long-term memory
Give a coding agent persistent decisions and bug fix notes
Kind
MCP server
MCP server
Pricing
Open source
Open source
Platforms
CLI, macOS, Windows, Linux, self-hosted
CLI, self-hosted, macOS, Linux, Windows
Runs
Locally
Locally
Open source
Good for
Give a desktop assistant private long-term memory; Erase a memory with a verifiable receipt; Link and summarise what an agent knows about a topic
Give a coding agent persistent decisions and bug fix notes; Index existing Claude Code auto-memory without importing; Keep separate memory for each agent in a fleet

What Citadel does

  • Encrypted memory

    Memory is AES-256 encrypted at rest and each atom is sealed and authenticated.

  • Hybrid recall

    Combines vector, keyword, recency and importance scores.

  • Memory graph

    Typed edges link atoms and can be expanded during recall.

  • Cryptographic forgetting

    Destroys keys to erase an atom or region.

  • Integrity checks

    mem_verify reports whether atoms are authentic, tampered or erased.

  • Local-first

    No API keys; data stays on your machine.

What cogvault does

  • Markdown source of truth

    Files stay editable; the index is a rebuildable cache.

  • Hybrid retrieval

    Vector plus BM25 fused with reciprocal rank fusion.

  • Multi-tenant isolation

    One directory per agent, one process.

  • Fully offline

    On-device embeddings; nothing leaves the machine.

  • Recall evaluation

    eval and analyze measure real recall quality.

  • Optional reranker

    Cross-encoder reranking in the shared daemon.

Citadel vs cogvault: questions

Is Citadel or cogvault cheaper?

Both are open source. Compare current plans on each official site.

What is the difference between Citadel and cogvault?

Citadel is an open-source MCP server for knowledge and memory. cogvault is an open-source MCP server for knowledge and memory.

Keep comparing