Skip to content

Base-rate card — Atom vs BotShelf Vampire

Base-rate card — Atom is an MCP server for agent tooling. BotShelf Vampire is an open-source MCP server for agent tooling.

  • Base-rate card — Atom is best for auditing a base-rate argument before it is used in a forecast or decision memo.
  • BotShelf Vampire is best for pull a free code review prompt or team recipe into an ai coding session.
What it is
Base-rate card — Atom is an MCP server for agent tooling.
BotShelf Vampire is an open-source MCP server for agent tooling.
Best for
Auditing a base-rate argument before it is used in a forecast or decision memo
Pull a free code review prompt or team recipe into an AI coding session
Kind
MCP server
MCP server
Pricing
Open source
Platforms
API
CLI, API, vscode
Runs
Remotely
Remotely
Open source
Good for
Auditing a base-rate argument before it is used in a forecast or decision memo; Checking that a reference class declaration includes counts and a stated rate; Standardising review of probabilistic claims across an analyst team
Pull a free code review prompt or team recipe into an AI coding session; Search a shared shelf of agent toolkits from inside an MCP client; Browse Grok Bot tool guides without leaving the editor

What Base-rate card — Atom does

  • Rate re-derivation check

    Recomputes the stated base rate from declared successes and class size to flag arithmetic mismatches.

  • Six-section card review

    Scores claim and evidence, reference class, steelman, fallacy spot-check, calibration and judgment separately.

  • Fallacy coverage check

    Tests whether the card addresses the named fallacies the skill screens for.

  • Per-check evidence output

    Returns each check's evidence alongside a CARD_COMPLETE, CARD_NOT_COMPLETE or INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE verdict.

  • Internal consistency only

    Audits the card's own record and does not source or validate external reference-class data.

What BotShelf Vampire does

  • Keyword search with filters

    Searches shelf items by every word in a query, with optional filters for kind, runtime, topic, access and check status.

  • Full text retrieval

    Returns the full text of free items that have a plain file open without sign-up, with long text split into parts.

  • Paged shelf listing

    Lists items in shelf order a page at a time and reports how many items each kind holds.

  • Read-only operation

    Offers no tools that post, purchase, sign in or modify anything on the site.

  • No account required

    Connects with a single address and no API key or sign-up.

Base-rate card — Atom vs BotShelf Vampire: questions

What is the difference between Base-rate card — Atom and BotShelf Vampire?

Base-rate card — Atom is an MCP server for agent tooling. BotShelf Vampire is an open-source MCP server for agent tooling.