Base-rate card — Atom vs BotShelf Vampire
Base-rate card — Atom is an MCP server for agent tooling. BotShelf Vampire is an open-source MCP server for agent tooling.
- Base-rate card — Atom is best for auditing a base-rate argument before it is used in a forecast or decision memo.
- BotShelf Vampire is best for pull a free code review prompt or team recipe into an ai coding session.
- What it is
- Base-rate card — Atom is an MCP server for agent tooling.BotShelf Vampire is an open-source MCP server for agent tooling.
- Best for
- Auditing a base-rate argument before it is used in a forecast or decision memoPull a free code review prompt or team recipe into an AI coding session
- Kind
- MCP serverMCP server
- Pricing
- Open source
- Platforms
- APICLI, API, vscode
- Runs
- RemotelyRemotely
- Open source
- Good for
- Auditing a base-rate argument before it is used in a forecast or decision memo; Checking that a reference class declaration includes counts and a stated rate; Standardising review of probabilistic claims across an analyst teamPull a free code review prompt or team recipe into an AI coding session; Search a shared shelf of agent toolkits from inside an MCP client; Browse Grok Bot tool guides without leaving the editor
What Base-rate card — Atom does
Rate re-derivation check
Recomputes the stated base rate from declared successes and class size to flag arithmetic mismatches.
Six-section card review
Scores claim and evidence, reference class, steelman, fallacy spot-check, calibration and judgment separately.
Fallacy coverage check
Tests whether the card addresses the named fallacies the skill screens for.
Per-check evidence output
Returns each check's evidence alongside a CARD_COMPLETE, CARD_NOT_COMPLETE or INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE verdict.
Internal consistency only
Audits the card's own record and does not source or validate external reference-class data.
What BotShelf Vampire does
Keyword search with filters
Searches shelf items by every word in a query, with optional filters for kind, runtime, topic, access and check status.
Full text retrieval
Returns the full text of free items that have a plain file open without sign-up, with long text split into parts.
Paged shelf listing
Lists items in shelf order a page at a time and reports how many items each kind holds.
Read-only operation
Offers no tools that post, purchase, sign in or modify anything on the site.
No account required
Connects with a single address and no API key or sign-up.
Base-rate card — Atom vs BotShelf Vampire: questions
What is the difference between Base-rate card — Atom and BotShelf Vampire?
Base-rate card — Atom is an MCP server for agent tooling. BotShelf Vampire is an open-source MCP server for agent tooling.
