Skip to content

ASTra vs MCP Server for Excel

ASTra is a freemium MCP server for files and documents. MCP Server for Excel is an open-source MCP server for files and documents.

  • MCP Server for Excel is open source, while ASTra is freemium.
  • ASTra is best for build a board report from notes.
  • MCP Server for Excel is best for import a csv with power query and load it to the data model.
What it is
ASTra is a freemium MCP server for files and documents.
MCP Server for Excel is an open-source MCP server for files and documents.
Best for
Build a board report from notes
Import a CSV with Power Query and load it to the Data Model
Kind
MCP server
MCP server
Pricing
Freemium
Open source
Platforms
CLI, self-hosted
Windows, CLI, vscode
Runs
Locally
Locally
GitHub stars
0
Last commit
Nov 2026
Open source
Good for
Build a board report from notes; Edit a table cell without breaking the file; Validate a generated contract before sending
Import a CSV with Power Query and load it to the Data Model; Build a PivotTable of revenue by region with a chart; Run Goal Seek to find a price that hits a profit target

What ASTra does

  • Stable IDs

    Paragraphs, tables and charts each have a handle.

  • Schema-checked saves

    Files are written only if validation passes.

  • Git-style history

    Every save is a commit, so edits can be undone.

  • Atomic batches

    Groups of operations apply together.

  • Sandboxed folders

    Access is limited to chosen folders.

What MCP Server for Excel does

  • Real Excel engine

    Automates the actual Excel app through COM rather than parsing files.

  • Power Query and M code

    Create, edit and refresh queries and manage load destinations.

  • Power Pivot and DAX

    Build Data Models, DAX measures and table relationships.

  • PivotTables and charts

    Create PivotTables and charts from ranges, tables or the Data Model.

  • VBA and Python in Excel

    View, import and run VBA modules and =PY() formulas.

  • Live view of the work

    Ask the agent to show Excel while it works and keep editing normally.

ASTra vs MCP Server for Excel: questions

Is ASTra or MCP Server for Excel cheaper?

MCP Server for Excel is the cheaper option: it is open source.

What is the difference between ASTra and MCP Server for Excel?

ASTra is a freemium MCP server for files and documents. MCP Server for Excel is an open-source MCP server for files and documents. MCP Server for Excel is open source, while ASTra is freemium.