Skip to content

AsDecided vs WhyKit

AsDecided is an open-source MCP server for developer tools. WhyKit is an open-source MCP server for developer tools.

  • AsDecided is best for tell a coding agent which decisions govern a path.
  • WhyKit is best for warn an ai coding agent before it undoes a deliberate design choice.
What it is
AsDecided is an open-source MCP server for developer tools.
WhyKit is an open-source MCP server for developer tools.
Best for
Tell a coding agent which decisions govern a path
Warn an AI coding agent before it undoes a deliberate design choice
Kind
MCP server
MCP server
Pricing
Open source
Open source
Platforms
CLI, self-hosted, macOS, Linux, Windows
CLI
Runs
Locally
Locally
Open source
Good for
Tell a coding agent which decisions govern a path; Cite an architecture decision in a pull request; Gate a merge on objectively checkable rules
Warn an AI coding agent before it undoes a deliberate design choice; Fail a pull request when a decision rests on retired evidence; Trace why a payment or webhook rule exists

What AsDecided does

  • Deterministic retrieval

    Returns the same cited decisions for the same repository state.

  • Stable decision IDs

    Lets agents cite the exact authority behind a plan or pull request.

  • Validation and gates

    Checks records and can gate code changes against decisions in CI.

  • Corpus federation

    Combines pinned parent corpora offline with source tracking.

  • Read-only MCP

    Serves records without writing to the repository.

  • No model dependency

    Needs no embeddings, hosted index or model call.

What WhyKit does

  • Change-to-decision mapping

    Lists which decisions a set of changed files touches.

  • Staleness checks

    Flags decisions whose sources were retired or whose review date has passed.

  • Read-only MCP

    Agents look up decisions without being able to change a file.

  • Sensitivity ceiling

    Limits what an agent can read by record sensitivity label.

  • CI gate

    A check command and GitHub Action fail pull requests that rest on dead evidence.

  • Plain Markdown vault

    Everything is files in Git, openable in Obsidian.

AsDecided vs WhyKit: questions

Is AsDecided or WhyKit cheaper?

Both are open source. Compare current plans on each official site.

What is the difference between AsDecided and WhyKit?

AsDecided is an open-source MCP server for developer tools. WhyKit is an open-source MCP server for developer tools.

Keep comparing