Side by side
- Who calls it. An API: code a developer wrote for that API. An MCP server: any AI app that supports MCP.
- How the caller learns what it does. An API: a developer reads its documentation. An MCP server: the app asks the server (
tools/list) and gets each tool's name, description and input schema. - Shape of the calls. An API: different for every API. An MCP server: the same for every server (
tools/callover JSON-RPC 2.0). - Who decides when to call. An API: the developer's code. An MCP server: the model, based on the tool descriptions, usually with your approval.
Without MCP
With MCP
How they fit together
An MCP server does not replace an API. A typical server for a web service takes a tool call from the AI app, turns it into one or more requests to the service's API, and returns the answer in a form the model can read. What MCP adds is the shared layer on top: the server describes its tools in a standard way, so the same server works in Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, VS Code and other MCP apps without each of them writing an integration.
Which one do you need?
- You are building software that calls a service directly: use its API.
- You want an AI assistant to use a service: look for an MCP server for it, ideally one published by the service itself. Search the MCP servers in the directory, or see how to add one.
- You run a service and want AI apps to use it: build an MCP server on top of your API.