# Kill My Idea

> Kill My Idea is a free MCP server for productivity. Scores startup and side-project ideas as KILL IT, FIX IT or SHIP IT from 0 to 100. It runs as a hosted remote server, so there is nothing to install locally.

- **Kind:** MCP server
- **Pricing:** Free
- **Platforms:** API
- **Website:** https://killmyidea.biz/mcp/
- **Repository:** https://github.com/monteduro/killmyidea
- **MCP Registry name:** biz.killmyidea/killmyidea
- **Categories:** productivity
- **Listing updated:** 2026-11-14

## About

The verdict comes from a scoring pipeline rather than a generative model. According to the README, one request puts ten questions in parallel to the TypeSafe Jev service, eight plain indie-hacker questions scored 0 to 4 plus the category and whether the idea is understandable. The scores are weighted into an average and a clarity gate produces the verdict. A result names the best signal and the biggest risk and lists eight sub-scores such as real problem, clear customer, demand, money, reach, different, buildable and shareable.

The goal argument changes the weighting: money (default), open_source, which swaps Money for Adoption, or fun, which swaps in immediate appeal and fun. Ideas must be 20 to 5,000 characters, and more detail gives a better verdict. A do_not_archive flag keeps confidential ideas from being stored; otherwise successful evaluations are archived.

The endpoint is a stateless Streamable HTTP server that needs no API key or sign-up, and the site says a verdict takes about a second. A second tool reports how many ideas were analysed and how they split between kill, fix and ship.

## Features

- **Three-way verdict:** KILL IT, FIX IT or SHIP IT with a 0-100 score.
- **Eight sub-scores:** Each score is weighted and listed with its note.
- **Goal modes:** Money, open source or fun change which dimensions count.
- **Opt-out archiving:** do_not_archive keeps an idea's text unstored.
- **Stateless endpoint:** No auth, sessions or keys.
- **Usage stats:** Counts of ideas killed, fixed and shipped.

## Good for

- Sanity-check a side project before building
- Compare ideas by score
- Find the weakest dimension of an idea
- Let an agent screen a list of ideas

## Install

### Claude Code (Terminal)

```sh
claude mcp add --transport http killmyidea https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp
```

### Claude Desktop (Settings → Connectors → Add custom connector)

```sh
https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp
```

### Cursor (~/.cursor/mcp.json)

```json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "killmyidea": {
      "url": "https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp"
    }
  }
}
```

### VS Code (.vscode/mcp.json)

```json
{
  "servers": {
    "killmyidea": {
      "type": "http",
      "url": "https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp"
    }
  }
}
```

### Windsurf (~/.codeium/windsurf/mcp_config.json)

```json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "killmyidea": {
      "serverUrl": "https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp"
    }
  }
}
```

### Other clients (your client's MCP settings (most use this shape))

```json
{
  "mcpServers": {
    "killmyidea": {
      "type": "http",
      "url": "https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp"
    }
  }
}
```

## Tools

- `judge_idea`: Judges an idea and returns verdict, score, best signal, biggest risk and eight sub-scores.
- `get_stats`: Returns how many ideas were analysed and the kill, fix and ship split.

## FAQ

### Is an API key required?

No. It is free and public with no sign-up.

### Is my idea stored?

Successful evaluations are archived unless you set do_not_archive to true.

### What does the goal setting do?

It changes which dimensions are scored: money, open source adoption or fun.

### How long should an idea be?

20 to 5,000 characters.

### Is Kill My Idea free?

Yes. Kill My Idea is free to use.

### How do I add Kill My Idea to Claude Code?

Run this command in your terminal: claude mcp add --transport http killmyidea https://killmyidea.biz/api/mcp

### What are the best alternatives to Kill My Idea?

The closest alternatives to Kill My Idea are Ha MCP, Concord MCP, note1, CalderFlow and nicemails.

## Alternatives

- [Ha MCP](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/ha-mcp): Ha MCP is an open-source MCP server for productivity.
- [Concord MCP](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/concord-mcp): Concord MCP is a freemium MCP server for developer tools.
- [note1](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/note1): note1 is an MCP server for productivity.
- [CalderFlow](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/calderflow): CalderFlow is a free MCP server for design and media.
- [nicemails](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/nicemails): nicemails is a freemium MCP server for communication.
- [ConvertAudioToText](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/convertaudiototext): ConvertAudioToText is a freemium MCP server for design and media.
- [MeetBetr](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/meetbetr): MeetBetr is a free MCP server for productivity.
- [Hostlet](https://ai-powered.com/mcp/hostlet): Hostlet is a free MCP server for productivity.

---
Source: https://ai-powered.com/mcp/kill-my-idea
